TikTok Broke Its Own Spell

TikTok still has Gen Z's attention, but the magic that kept them there is fading. And maybe that's a good thing.

We ran a grand experiment. We told ourselves social media was going to connect us, make us feel whole, give us community. And instead we ended up at the end of the looking glass, staring at our own reflections, asking: is this actually what we wanted?

Nowhere is that question louder right now than on TikTok. I’ve been talking to journalists lately, Fortune, MediaPost, Forbes, and the conversation always starts in the same place. The ban, the sale, the political theater.

But the story underneath all of that is more interesting. It’s about a generation grieving a platform they’re still actively using. And an algorithm that once felt like magic, that knew you better than you knew yourself, that built you a television channel from your own diary, and now that no longer works the way it used to.

Our data shows the magic is already fading.

A Six-Year-Old Platform With a Nostalgia Problem

Here’s the data point that stopped me in our recent research on social media.

79% of Gen Z TikTok users say they miss the early days of TikTok. Let’s put that in perspective, TikTok only entered the chat from a mainstream POV in 2020.

We are talking about six years of nostalgia. And Gen Z is grieving a platform they’re still actively using.

The platform they fell in love with is already gone in their minds.

And yet, Gen Z still predominantly turns to TikTok first for culture. 37% go there before anywhere else for entertainment, pop culture, and local experiences. Nearly double any other platform (e.g., YouTube, Instagram, Snap ect). No other generation relies on a single app this heavily. TikTok still holds the cultural crown. The question is how long the loyalty holds when the experience keeps eroding underneath it.

Because the cracks are real. 59% of Gen Z trust TikTok less than they used to. 53% feel it's more censored. 73% say the content feels staged and performative. 43% say it feels more mentally draining than it did a year ago. This isn't vague dissatisfaction. This is active, awake skepticism from the most marketing-savvy generation alive.

The Passive Bargain Is Broken

But here’s what everyone misses: what made TikTok genuinely unlike anything before it was that it asked almost nothing of you. You didn’t have to search. You didn’t have to follow the right people or carefully curate your taste. You just opened the app and it found you. It was passive entertainment that felt almost eerily personal, a feed so dialed in that users described it as knowing them better than they knew themselves.

That was the bargain. TikTok did the work. You just watched.

But when the algorithm breaks, when you have to actively train it and the content feels staged and generic, that passive spell lifts. Since the ownership change, 33% of Gen Z say the algorithm simply isn't as personalized or relevant anymore. Another 33% say they now have to consciously train it just to get content they actually want. That's not scrolling. That's labor

And here’s where it gets interesting. When something that was effortless suddenly requires effort, people pause. They look up. They look around. And in that pause lives a question that TikTok’s frictionless design was specifically built to prevent: is this actually how I want to be spending my time? The disruption of the algo might be the most unintentional gift TikTok has ever given its users. A forced moment to reassess a habit they never consciously chose.

That reassessment is where behavioral change actually begins.

TikTok Is Still For Discovery, But Missing Check Out

TechCrunch reported that TikTok’s numbers bounced back, from a brief dip to 86-88 million daily active users post-ownership change, to back over 90 million. Stability on the surface. But 32% of TikTok users say they’re witnessing creators leaving the platform, which is a longer-term signal worth watching.

For brands, the commerce picture is equally sobering. 62% of Gen Z still use TikTok to discover new products. But 63% have stopped buying through TikTok Shop. Discovery, yes. Checkout, no. TikTok can still put things on the radar. Don’t bank on it as your point of conversion.

Touch Grass Is Not Just a Meme — It’s a Movement

Last week I was on a panel at Advertising Week called Touch Grass, all about Gen Z’s desire to get offline.

Anthony Po, an experiential artist and the creative mind behind the viral Timothée Chalamet look-alike contest and the recent Touch Grass experience, talked about his mission to get people to convene without commercial interests. Not to buy, not to consume, just to be in the same physical space together.

And sitting on that stage, I kept thinking about how this connects directly to TikTok’s broken bargain. When the thing that was effortlessly spoon-feeding you your own reflection stops working, some people will simply choose to close the app entirely.

Our data backs this up.

And when we asked Gen Z what they want instead of scrolling, nobody said "find a better app." They want to exercise. See their friends in person. Make things. The instinct isn't toward another platform — it's toward a better life.

YouTube Is Quietly Winning the Living Room

While everyone debates TikTok’s future, YouTube has become the undisputed king of Gen Z’s attention, and I don’t think we’re talking about it enough. 66% of Gen Z uses YouTube daily. 44% plan to use it more next year, only 6% are cutting back (lowest of any social platform). 91% favorable rating. YouTube is the serious long-term relationship while everything else is a chaotic situationship.

But here’s the quieter signal worth watching: Substack 11% of Gen Z uses it daily, the same rate as Millennials, and nearly a quarter (24%) use it monthly. One of the Gen Z panelists, Reid Litman, on my Advertising Week panel said something I haven’t stopped thinking about. He said you can touch grass on Substack. Getting offline isn’t always about closing the laptop. Sometimes it’s about being intentional about what you let into your mind and being conscious of what a platform is doing to your subconscious while you scroll. That reframe matters enormously for where media and marketing are heading.

The Bigger Shift

Here’s where I land. Social media is starting to feel like what email felt like ten years ago. It’s infrastructure. It’s there. It’s necessary. But it’s no longer new or electric. AI is the thing bouldering its way into our conversations now, capturing the cultural imagination that social once held.

I hope social media’s role shifts from foreground to background noise in our lives. A tool that helps people find their niche community and then pushes them offline to actually meet those people in person. As 76% of Americans say, “the best social media trends are those that show up IRL.”

And maybe the TikTok reset is actually the gift nobody asked for. When the thing you reach for automatically suddenly requires effort, it creates a rare opening. A moment to look up, look around, and ask: is this actually how I want to spend the minutes of my day?

Because those minutes, accumulated, are your life.

Big Shout out to Amalba Kola who ran this study!

_________________________________________________________________________

Curiosity is contagious; if you like this newsletter, please share it!!

Penned by Libby Rodney and Abbey Lunney, founders of the Thought Leadership + Futures Group at The Harris Poll. Thanks for reading The Next Big Think! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.